Translated from Latin, altar means “altar,” i.e., a pedestal where a sacrifice is burned. Previously, it was considered so - this is a place for making ritual offerings. Now the altar does not have such a function, but still remains the most important part of the temple. There are certain requirements for being at the altar, which we will talk about today. After all ordinary people often interested . For example, why women are not allowed to enter the altar.

The concept of the altar among Catholics and Orthodox

• In Orthodoxy The altar is the name given to the eastern part of the temple, which only priests are allowed to enter. It is usually separated from the prayer hall by an iconostasis or simply a fence. And already in the altar itself there is a throne on which the objects necessary for the rituals are located: the Gospel, the antimension and the cross.
• In Catholicism The throne itself is called the altar. They also place a cross, the Gospel, and sometimes items for communion on it: wine and bread. Here the altar is not fenced off, but open. Its purpose is to perform the sacraments. Sometimes several altars are installed at once, more often in large churches.

Certain Requirements to be Observed by the Church

• For both Catholics and Orthodox Christians, the altar should be located in the eastern part of the temple and face east.
• Catholics should have no more than one service per day at one altar. This sometimes explains the presence of several altars in one temple.
• In Orthodoxy, only clergy of the highest hierarchy are allowed into the altar.
• According to the law of church law, only presbyters, bishops and deacons can receive communion at the altar. But in practice, it is sometimes allowed for the laity to receive communion at the altar (in exceptional cases). For example, students of theological seminaries.

Only altar servers are allowed to the altar. These are men who, of their own free will, assist the clergy at the altar. That's why they are called that.

Altar servers have their own responsibilities and rules

• Before entering the altar, you must kiss the icon on the gate.
• Then bow three times with sign of the cross. On weekdays - prostrations, on holidays - zone.
• Next, ask for a blessing from the located priest.
• When passing near a mountainous place, you need to cross yourself.
• Under no circumstances should you talk or laugh loudly.
• During the Gospel, the reading of the canon and the Cherubic song, noise must not be allowed. Only prayer should be heard.
• It is strictly forbidden to touch the throne and the altar.
• It is necessary to try to walk in front of the Throne as little as possible.
• You cannot bring any food with you.
• It is forbidden to pass through the Royal Gate.
• It is unacceptable to carry technical equipment with you.
• It is also undesirable to distract the clergyman with questions.
• In case of any external bleeding, the altar server must leave.

In some nunneries, women - nuns in old age - are allowed into this part. And even less often is one of the parishioners allowed to the altar.

Let's try to understand why the limits of being at the altar for the laity are so strict.

According to Archimandrite Alypiy Svetlichny, the exclusion of this category of parishioners occurs for objective reasons:

• Women - due to “monthly involuntary flow”.
• Ordinary parishioners - because the altar is a sanctuary.

The altar is the center, order should reign there. That is why it is separated from the rest of the temple area in order to preserve the sanctity of this place. Eliminate fuss, noise and crowding, which is inevitable with large crowds of people.

If all lay people are allowed to enter the altar, it will cease to be a sacred place, but will become a place of passage. And hence - a completely understandable disorder and, accordingly, obstacles to the performance of sacred rites.

So, we tried to give answers to the questions that interest you, one of which is “Why are women not allowed to enter the altar?”

Why do priests not allow women into the altar? Why are there places in the church that are prohibited for women? Woman what, worse than a man? - Archimandrite Alipiy (Svetlichny) answers.

So, a woman, from the point of view of the Church, is not at all something unclean

As some liberal-minded individuals suspect. Otherwise, the Church would not have extolled the Most Pure Mother of God so much! I would not honor the host of holy wives and virgins.

Moreover, in the concept of Moral Theology there is no significant difference between a man and a woman, a layman and a priest. Theology sees us as people! People who go to salvation, or people who doom themselves to death. Only such a division.

Interpreting the 15th Rule of the Council of Chalcedon, Balsamon writes: “What is said in this rule has completely fallen out of use; for now deaconesses are not ordained, although some ascetics are not in the proper sense called deaconesses; because there is a rule that women should not enter the holy altar. So, she who cannot enter the holy altar, how will she fulfill the duties of a deacon?” So we stumbled! It turns out that there is a rule stipulating that women should not enter the altar... So, it seems, discrimination begins...

Let's look for such a rule to understand why women are not allowed to enter the sacred altar

Let us turn to the Syntagma and look at Chapter 22, “That women should not enter the holy altar.” We read: “The 44th canon of the Council of Laodicea considers it inappropriate for the holy altar to be accessible to women, although previously it was also allowed to them. For if this is prohibited for male laymen (by the 69th rule of the VI Ecumenical Council), then even more so it should (be prohibited) for women. And (women are not allowed into the holy altar), as some say, for reasons of involuntary menstruation.”

So that's what it's all about! It turns out that lay men are also prohibited from entering the altar! This is how the 69th Rule of the Sixth Ecumenical Council speaks about this: “None of all those belonging to the category of laity will be allowed to enter the sacred altar. But according to some ancient legend, this is by no means forbidden to the power and dignity of the king when he desires to bring gifts to the Creator.”

So, it is only permissible for the king to enter from the laity, both because he is the anointed one, and only when he brings a gift, i.e. royal ritual gift to the church.

Let's try to understand why the Rule does not allow the laity into the altar

I think that there is no need to look for explanatory rules: it’s already clear! The sanctuary is necessary in order for sacred ceremonies to take place. It was separated from the space of the temple so that this place would not only be especially holy, but also to prevent disorder and crowding, which happens in the case of large quantity people in church, especially on holidays.

The altar should be the focus of prayer and exceptional order. This is especially important in view of the fact that at the holy meal there is a Chalice with the Divine Blood! At the table - the Lamb of God in the form of Bread! No one should push anyone inadvertently, but there is attention and reverence in everything.

If lay people begin to enter the altar, then the altar will become a passing place, and soon there will be disorder and inconvenience during the sacred ceremony!

And today you can see how the laity sometimes annoy priests who have left the altar for some business. Everyone needs to say something, ask something, give them a note with a lot of explanations, or even give them a gift, and sometimes express a remark or complaint with indignation. Some try to establish their own customs at the place where they stand... And all this can enter the altar!

Therefore, it was a completely wise decision of the Holy Fathers that only those serving the Holy Mysteries should be in the altar!

However, time has made amendments to the Council decrees, and today we can see some lay people in the altar. But for what purpose are they there?

Are they loitering? No - servants. Since the Helmsman’s Book says that a priest does not dare begin to serve the Liturgy if he does not have a sexton serving...

And then we suddenly encounter another oddity. In convents you can see nuns at the altar! And it is for the same purpose that they are allowed to enter the altar - they serve during the service!

This means that the Church still does not consider women inferior to men!

Simply, there must be measure in everything, and there must be meaning and order in everything in the Church of God.

And if a woman accidentally entered the altar, this does not mean that she desecrated it. No. But this means that she violated church order and sinned against the Church. And this is a reason to repent and, realizing your guilt, not to do this again, but to be modest and know your place and role. How do musicians know their instrument and part in order to Symphony Orchestra sounded coherent and worthy of the piece they intended to perform. Otherwise - cacophony!

The altar is a sacred place for any Christian. IN Orthodox churches the altar is fenced off from the views of parishioners by the iconostasis, but in Catholic churches open. However, the rules of behavior in the Holy of Holies are similar in many areas of Christianity.

The ban is not just for women

In ancient times, when Christianity was still in its infancy, only the high priest could enter the altar and only once a year. In 364 at the Council, that is, at a meeting Orthodox priests, which took place in the city of Laodicea, rule number 44 was approved, which read: “It is not proper for a woman to enter the altar.”

Later, at the Sixth Ecumenical Council, held in 680 in Constantinople, the clergy decided that henceforth no layman should enter the altar, with the exception of representatives of the authorities who want to bring gifts to God.

Even the question of whether a male monk could attend the altar was somewhat controversial. However, Patriarch Nicholas of Constantinople expressed the opinion that a monk should not be prohibited from entering the altar, but he could only do this in order to light lamps and candles there, that is, during his service.

Women at the altar

However, even Princess Dashkova herself somehow forgot about the 44th rule of the Council of Laodicea. One day, together with her young son, at the invitation of Catherine, she went to the Hermitage. Having gotten lost in the palace, Dashkova asked the courtiers how to get to the Hermitage.

And they, wanting to make fun of her, answered: “Through the altar.” Without thinking twice, the princess rushed to the holy of holies. Having learned about Dashkova’s act, the Empress became furious. "Shame on you! – exclaimed Catherine. “You are Russian and you don’t know your law!”

To this day, in an Orthodox church, entry into the altar is allowed only to men who have received the blessing of the priest, for example, clergy (altar servers and readers). Women are strictly prohibited from entering there.

This prohibition is not explained by the fact that a woman is an unclean creature, as many mistakenly believe. None of the parishioners are allowed to enter this sacred room without a blessing. However, priests give this blessing exclusively to representatives of the male gender. The whole point is that in the temple, and especially in the altar, it is forbidden to shed blood. That’s why women are not allowed here because of the “monthly involuntary flow.”

Although there are exceptions to this rule. Thus, in women's monasteries, elderly nuns are allowed to enter the altar and perform obedience there. However, this too is done exclusively with the blessing of the archpriest.

What about Catholics?

In all Christian churches the altar takes pride of place. Representatives of all denominations of Christianity treat this sacred place with special reverence. IN catholic church the altar or presbytery is behind a low partition, and it is not difficult for anyone to step over it. However, this should not be done, since ordinary parishioners are prohibited from doing this in the same way as in Orthodox churches. Ordinary laity are allowed to enter the presbytery only in cases of extreme necessity.

Why can't a woman do what a man can? Is she really worse? We offer you a number of references on this matter:

Why can't a woman be a priest?

Centuries-old Orthodox church tradition I have never known female “priests”; the practice of “ordaining” women to the priesthood and episcopal rank is not accepted by the Orthodox Church.
There are several arguments against the female priesthood. First, “the priest at the liturgy is the liturgical icon of Christ, and the altar is the room of the Last Supper. At this supper, it was Christ who took the cup and said: drink, this is My Blood. …We partake of the Blood of Christ, which He Himself gave, which is why the priest must be the liturgical icon of Christ. ...Therefore, the priestly archetype (prototype) is male, not female” (Deacon Andrey Kuraev, “in the world of people”).
Secondly, a priest is a shepherd, and a woman, created as a helper, herself needs support and advice and therefore cannot carry out pastoral service in its entirety. She is called to fulfill her calling in motherhood.
An equally weighty argument is the absence of the very idea of ​​a female priesthood in Church Tradition. " Sacred Tradition“This is not just a tradition,” explained to us the professor of the Moscow Theological Academy, Doctor of Theology A.I. Osipov. — It is important to be able to distinguish random traditions from traditions with deep religious roots. There are strong arguments that the absence of a female priesthood is an essential tradition. In the history of the Church, the first century is called the century of extraordinary gifts. Simultaneously with baptism, people received gifts, some of them several at once: prophecy, the gift of tongues, the gift of healing diseases, casting out demons... Gifts obvious to everyone amazed the pagans, convincing them of the significance and power of Christianity. In this age we see a different attitude towards the Jewish Law, from which Christianity historically (but not ontologically) emerged. In particular, a different attitude towards women. Among the saints of that time there are Equal to the Apostles Mary Magdalene, Thekla - women who, in their talents, were on the same level as the apostles, did the same thing - preaching Christianity. But nowhere and never was the level of their church veneration connected with the granting of the priesthood to them.
Moreover, when in the II-III centuries. A female priesthood appeared in the Marcionite sect; this caused a strong protest from a number of revered saints and teachers of the Church.
The Mother of God, revered above the Angels, was not a priest.
The issue of the inadmissibility of the female priesthood is not covered in detail in theological literature: there are only isolated statements on this matter. But the fact is that in science a new theory is accepted only when there are new facts that confirm it, and fundamental shortcomings inherent in the previous theory. Theology is also a science. So, according to a principle common to all sciences, theological arguments should be presented not by opponents of the female priesthood, but by its defenders. These arguments can only come from two sources - Holy Scripture and the teachings of the Holy Fathers. “Neither in Scripture nor in patristic literature is there a single fact confirming the possibility of a female priesthood.”

For reference: the first female “priest” in the history of Christianity appeared in one of the churches of the Anglican Commonwealth (an association of Anglican churches around the world). Her name was Florence Lee Tim Oy (1907–1992). In 1941, after receiving her theological training, she became a deaconess and served the Chinese refugee community in Macau. When the Japanese occupation of China left the Macau congregation without a priest, the Anglican bishop of Hong Kong ordained her to the priesthood. It was a forced step. Because this was 30 years before any Anglican Church officially allowed female priesthood, Dr. Lee Tim Oi ceased priestly ministry immediately after the end of World War II. She died in 1992 in Toronto; By this time, the female “priesthood” had been introduced in most Anglican churches; the further, the more they deviated from the apostolic institutions, not only in this matter. “Why do Protestants dare to introduce female priests? There is internal contradiction, - believes O. Job (Gumerov), teacher of sacred history Old Testament Moscow Sretensky Seminary. - After all, in disputes with Orthodox Protestants, almost, they say: “Where does it say this in the Bible?” But on the issue of the female priesthood, they act in exactly the opposite way. Reasoning that if the Bible does not say “no”, then it is possible is formalism, deceit and a refusal to perceive the true spirit of Holy Scripture.”
The deceased believed that from a theological point of view, the question of a woman’s vocation had yet to be worked out. “I am convinced that we must think about this problem with all the strength of our minds, with full knowledge of Scripture and Tradition, and find an answer” (“Orthodox and women's question", Bulletin of the RSHD, II-2002). The Bishop wrote about the height and responsibility of the priestly calling: “The priesthood is a state filled with such fear that it is impossible to desire it. It can be accepted almost with sacred awe, with horror, and therefore the priesthood is not a matter of status, unless we reduce the priesthood to the level of unskilled public work and preaching and a kind of “Christian social service.”
The words of the Apostolic Epistles about all believers are known: “You are a chosen race, a royal priesthood, a holy nation, a people taken for His own inheritance, in order to proclaim the perfections of Him who called you out of darkness into His wonderful light” (). How to understand these words? explains this thought thus: “It seems to me that we can answer that the universal priesthood consists in the calling of all those who belong to Christ Himself, who through baptism have become Christ’s ... to sanctify this world, to make it sacred and holy, to offer it as a gift to God. This service consists, first of all, of offering one’s own soul and body to God as a living sacrifice, and in this offering of oneself, offering everything that is ours: not only feelings, and soul, and thoughts, and will, and the whole body, but everything we do, everything we touch, everything that belongs to us, everything that we can free with our power from slavery to Satan is through the act of our own faithfulness to God.”
Protopresbyter in his famous work The “Church of the Holy Spirit” separates the ministry of the royal priesthood – common to all the faithful, and the ministry of government – ​​shepherding or “special”, hierarchical priesthood. The royal priesthood is understood in only one way - as the co-service of the entire church community in the celebration of the Eucharist. But the assembly of the faithful cannot exist without a primate, a shepherd who has received special gifts of governance. “Government belongs only to those specially called, and not to the entire people, whose members have not received the gifts of government, and without grace-filled gifts there can be no service in the Church. Therefore, the ministry of shepherds is different from the ministry of God’s people.” It is precisely this kind of pastoral service (presbyterian and episcopal), according to Tradition, that women are not allowed to serve.

Have women always been excluded from the altar?

Widows, virgins or nuns after 40 years can become an altar server - that is, clean the altar, serve the censer, read, go out with candles. In the Holy Land, in the Church of the Holy Sepulcher, any pilgrim or pilgrim can enter the Edicule - the cave where Christ was resurrected and which serves as the altar of the temple - and venerate the deathbed of the Savior, that is, St. to the throne. Many are confused by the fact that at Baptism, boys are brought into the altar, but girls are not. However, it is known that until the 14th century, all children on the fortieth day after birth were churched (“fortiethly”) - brought into the altar. Moreover, both boys and girls were applied to St. to the throne. Children were baptized at about three years old, and infants only in case of danger. Later, after children began to be baptized earlier, the rite of churching began to be performed not before, but immediately after Baptism, and then girls were no longer brought to the altar, and boys were no longer brought to the Holy Cross. to the throne.

Why are women not allowed to visit Mount Athos?

Holy Mount Athos is a peninsula in Greece on which 20 large monasteries are located (not counting smaller monastic communities). Entrance to everything in Byzantium monasteries women were strictly prohibited. The Holy Mountain is considered the earthly inheritance of the Mother of God - legend says that Holy Mother of God and the Evangelist John set off on a sea voyage, but were caught in a storm on the way and lost their course, eventually landing at the foot of Mount Athos, in the place where the Iveron Monastery is now located. Struck by the beauty of these places, the Mother of God asked the Lord to make the Holy Mountain Her earthly inheritance. According to the covenant of the Mother of God, no woman except Her can set foot on the land of Athos. In 1045, with Byzantine emperor Constantine IX Monomakh adopted a charter for Athonites, officially prohibiting women and even female domestic animals from being on the territory of the Holy Mountain. A 1953 Greek presidential decree provides for imprisonment of 2 to 12 months for women who violate the ban (it must be said that during civil war in Greece 1946–1949 refugee women found refuge on the Holy Mountain, as they did more than once during Turkish rule). Maintaining the ban was one of the conditions put forward by Greece for joining the European Union. Despite this, various EU bodies periodically try to challenge this point. Until now, this has not been possible, since Athos is formally in private ownership - the entire territory of the mountain is divided into twenty parts between the monasteries located here. It should be noted that the Byzantine ban on visiting monasteries by persons of the opposite sex in Greece is still observed quite strictly - not only on Athos, but in many monasteries women are not allowed, and men (except for serving clergy) are not allowed into most nunneries.

Where did the deaconesses go?

Deaconesses as a special female church ministry appeared around the 4th century after the Nativity of Christ (although Deaconess Thebes is mentioned in the Epistle of the Apostle Paul to the Romans, historians believe that at that time the rite of becoming a deaconess had not yet been established). In the subsequent Byzantine tradition, unmarried women over 50 years of age could become deaconesses: widows, virgins, and also nuns. The order of the rites of ordination of a deaconess and a deacon was almost the same (but the prayers of ordination, of course, were different) - at the end of the ordination the deacon was given the Chalice, and he went to give communion to the believers, and the deaconess put the Chalice back on the Holy. throne. This expressed the fact that the deaconess had no liturgical duties (the only known independent role of deaconesses in worship was related to maintaining decency during the Baptism of women: after the bishop or priest poured holy oil on the forehead of the baptized person, the rest of the body was anointed by the deaconess). Deaconesses performed administrative functions in charitable institutions and led women's communities. In Byzantium, deaconesses existed until the 11th century (by this time only schema-nuns could become deaconesses); in the West, they disappeared about half a millennium earlier - largely due to the destruction of that social structure, within which they were required. In Byzantium, the need for deaconesses disappeared for similar reasons - social charitable institutions no longer needed them. Later, the institution of deaconesses was not restored, since there was no need for them. True, several deaconesses were ordained by the saint (1846–1920), the founder of a convent on the Greek island of Aegina, but this experience did not continue. There have never been deaconesses in Russia - in the oldest Slavic manuscript of the rites of ordination (bishop's Trebnik RNL. Sof. 1056, XIV century) the rite of ordination of a deaconess is absent.

Why do men and women stand separately in some temples?

According to a tradition dating back to early Christian times, men and women stand separately in the church. This division corresponded to ancient ideas about piety. The conventional division of the temple into male and female halves is still preserved, for example, among the Copts. In Byzantium, many churches had choirs (second floors running along the perimeter of the temple), where women stood during services.

Just a rib or the whole half?
According to one interpretation of the Bible, God created woman not from the man Adam, but from the man Adam, dividing him into two halves: male and female. Metropolitan Sourozhsky Anthony comments on this passage: “Bible translations often say that God took Adam's rib (). The Hebrew text offers other translations, one of which speaks of a side rather than an edge. God did not separate the rib, but separated two sides, two halves, female and male. Indeed, when you read the text in Hebrew, it becomes clear what Adam is saying when he comes face to face with Eve. He exclaims: she is a wife because I am a husband (). In Hebrew it sounds: ish and isha, the same word in the masculine and feminine. Together they make up a person, and they see each other in a new richness, in a new opportunity to grow what is already given into a new fullness.

The horrors of Domostroy are exaggerated

For some reason it is believed that all the horrors of traditional family life are described in “Domostroy” - a Russian family charter of the 16th century (the famous priest Sylvester was the author of only one of the editions of “Domostroy”). However, in this book we find only one quote that can be interpreted as encouraging Physical punishment for women: “If the husband sees that his wife is not in order and that the servants are not as well as in this book, he would be able to instruct and teach his wife useful advice; if she understands, then let her do everything like that, and respect her and favor her, but if the wife is such a science, does not follow the instructions and does not fulfill it (as is said in this book), and she herself does not know any of this, and the servants do not teaches, a husband must punish his wife, admonish her with fear in private, and having punished her, forgive and reproach, and gently instruct, and teach, but at the same time neither the husband should be offended by his wife, nor the wife by her husband - always live in love and harmony.”

Imperfections

We conducted a short survey of men regarding what typical qualities of women could be called “imperfections.” Most common answers:
- excessive emotionality
- talkativeness
– illogic of thinking and behavior
– excessive attention to appearance – your own and not only
– a woman prefers discussion to thinking and analysis
- quarrelsomeness
– envy
In general, we can say: the lack of independence and lack of self-sufficiency of women is a consequence of the fact that a woman was created as an assistant to a man, and not on her own

Is no one offended?
How widespread is dissatisfaction among church women with the place the Church assigns them? We asked several prominent Orthodox women about this (see below). To our surprise, there was not a single offended person among our interlocutors!
Maybe the fact is that in the Church any conversation from the position of “I have the right” is completely unfruitful? None of us - men or women, it doesn’t matter - can demand anything “for ourselves” - because love does not seek its own. You can only demand from yourself. How good it is that it is easier for the feminine, softer and more compliant nature to understand this!
What should those who are still offended do: men won’t let them say a word? I think there is some consolation. If you really have something to say, and the content of your soul and your words is really important, you don’t have to be afraid, you will be heard. How the holy women were heard - so much so that the memory of them and their words were preserved through the centuries.
Yulia Danilova, editor-in-chief of Neskuchny Sad magazine

Why should women remain silent?

In our age of feminism, the church’s attitude towards women, at first glance, seems discriminatory, even outrageous. But this is only at first glance, from the outside. Judging by our survey of women themselves, they do not think so at all

“Let your wives be silent in churches...” () Women are not allowed to be priests. They are not allowed into the altar or on Mount Athos. Don't Orthodox Christian women feel offended? - we asked famous women countries.

Natalya Loseva, head of Internet projects at RIA Novosti:
– In my opinion, it doesn’t hurt to bring back some traditions of behavior between men and women in the church: for example, the custom of women standing on the left and men on the right.
I think (to the extent that I am generally allowed to comment on the apostles) that the words “let a woman remain silent in the Church” are true for all times. And in their literal interpretation, implying reverent silence. How many times have I cut myself off when you stand at the cross and while away the minutes chatting with a friend, and next to you are the communicants who are experiencing their Silence at this time, reading thanksgiving prayers or the prayer service began. They are all the more true, in my opinion, in the sense that it is not a woman’s place to preach at the altar, and there is nothing offensive or derogatory in this, because the laws and traditions of the fathers do not carry a ritual, but a deep, sacred meaning.
Are you offended that a man does not give birth to children and does not have regular illnesses? What about the fact that you can't grow a beard? Why is it that each of us is ready to calmly and naturally accept bodily, physiological differences, but someone resists another, more subtle difference? I’ll tell you moreover, I’m afraid that one day, for the sake of pseudo-liberalism, a woman’s foot will set foot on Athos. There are traditions that we need to hold on to with our teeth, even if we cannot comprehend their full, real, unconditional meaning.
Recently, my friends and I said, going through our “Orthodox crowd,” that if a man came from a non-church family in adulthood to the Church, then this is a cement adhesion. They are stronger in faith.

Irina Yakovlevna Medvedeva, Orthodox psychologist:
“I think that the apostle’s words refer to those times when not only clergy, but also male laymen had the right to preach in church. I’m not at all offended that I’m not allowed into the altar. It is much more offensive when men do not give way to women or do not shake hands when exiting a vehicle. And only weak and inferior men in some respects assert themselves at the expense of women. After all, a woman is undoubtedly weaker than a man when it comes to generosity and condescension.

Antonina Vasilievna Mitiguz, Lieutenant Colonel of the Internal Service of the Ministry of Justice of the Russian Federation:
– If you stick to church rules, then men approach the cross and the chalice first. And I am pleased to let the men go first - this is my tribute to those few men who go to church today.
In women, the tongue very often precedes the mind, so the common phrase: “My tongue is my enemy,” unfortunately, characterizes the majority of women. I also try not to forget the words of Rev. , who warned that “sorrows are sent to those who talk in the temple.”
From my personal observations, I can say that if a man came to faith, he did it consciously and seriously. Moreover, he is likely to be a true soldier of Christ and will not show off his faith and his good works. A woman loves external manifestations and discussions of her affairs and is often touched by her outwardly pious appearance. During fasting, a woman often pays serious attention to food restrictions rather than working on her inner content.

Abbess of the Novo-Tikhvin Monastery Lyubov (Nesterenko):
– It is enough that the Apostle Paul said this, and there would be no need to argue further. The Word of God is immutable. The Book of Proverbs says: “Do not transgress (that is, do not cross, do not violate) the limit of the eternal” (22, 28), and the Savior Himself said: “Heaven and earth will pass away, but My words will not pass away.” This is an eternal law and it is sacred to us. An example can be given from the First Book of Chronicles. When the ark of God was being transported, Uzzah, not being a priest, touched it and died at the same moment. It would seem, what bad did he do? He just wanted to support the ark so that it would not fall off the chariot. But he rushed into a ministry that was not intended for him. In the same way, when we dare to transgress the limits set by the Word of God regarding our ministry, we die. Moreover, we may not even feel this death, since we live more spiritual life than spiritual, and some spiritual things are completely unknown to us. But if we do not feel this now, during the days of our earthly life, then the consequences of this will certainly appear when we cross the threshold of death.
If we sincerely believe, and do not just call ourselves Christians, then we submit with love to Divine Revelation. Then we develop an appropriate heart structure, and it does not even occur to us to think about whether we are being oppressed or not. If we go beyond the scope of Holy Scripture, then we enter, so to speak, into the realm of passions, and naturally, vanity, pride, dissatisfaction with our position and grumbling against Divine institutions arise in us.
Holy Bible assigns a certain role to women. If we turn to the Book of Genesis, we will see that the Lord created Eve precisely as a helper. What is a helper? Even in our modern understanding, this is a person with disabilities.
From the point of view of natural talents, women are inferior to men in physical strength, and also in intellectual terms. Which women became famous in the field of philosophy or theology? On the other hand, as Christians we should not talk only about natural abilities. For us, another question is more important: who is superior in terms of knowledge of God? And about this most important subject for us, the Holy Scripture says that in this we are equal - “there is neither male nor female” (). With regard to the knowledge of God - it should be emphasized: not theoretical, but living, experimental knowledge of God - women are in no way inferior to men. When we're talking about about communion with God, even some natural “deficiencies” are covered by Divine grace. For example, if we talk about bodily weakness, we can cite the example of the martyrs who, by the power of Christ, endured supernatural torments, torments no less than those that befell men. Let us remember the martyr Felicity. She could not hold back her screams when she gave birth (she was imprisoned while pregnant), and a few days later she endured terrible torment for Christ without a single groan. Also, regarding the depth of reasoning, the words of the Savior were fulfilled not only on men, but also on women: “When they bring you into the synagogues, before the principalities and powers, do not worry about how or what to answer, or what to say, for the Holy Spirit will teach you in the hour that must be spoken" (). So, we are equal in the most important thing, we have the same calling, and on our path to the Kingdom of God, only our own determination and zeal for salvation matters.

Elena Soboleva, author of the book “The Fifth Angel Sounded”, film director, teacher at domestic and foreign film schools:
– In general, it’s very difficult to oppress me - I’m still a film director, I know how to stand up for myself in any situation. But, in general, no one ever offends me, because people simply feel at first glance some kind of personal status.
We don't really need to go into the altar. But questions about, say, bare head or a reconsidered attitude towards makeup may be subject to discussion. I don’t think that our royal new martyrs - queens and princesses - walked around without jewelry and without makeup. However, this did not stop them from becoming saints.
Our history is moving towards the end of the world. This is also reflected in the fact that the male sex is becoming more and more decorative. It no longer corresponds at all to the traditions that have existed for thousands of years in human society. Almost every politician has female ears sticking out. Who made, for example, Clinton Clinton, and Gorbachev Gorbachev?
A woman has less of this desire to prance and compete. Men compete with each other from birth to death. And a woman is characterized by self-sacrifice - she takes care of her husband and children. Therefore, a woman is more likely to be constancy. And a man is disposable. He can wave a sword, show courage once, accomplish a feat and lay down his head. This is the most changeable group of humanity - men. And therefore they are especially affected by modern and ecological problems, and social.

Frederica-Maria de Graas, psychologist and massage therapist, volunteer employee of the Moscow Hospice:
“There are few men in the church, much less than women, and I don’t feel any oppression on their part.
I think the apostle called on women to leave idle talk in order to feel their unity with God in the Temple. It is much easier for a woman to do this than for a man, since she is more sensitive and intuitive. The Apostle said that a woman should give up her curiosity, envy and desire to talk - then her natural ability to perceive the presence of God will turn on. It is easier for her to accept this than for a man. “Let a woman remain silent in church” in order to serve God and be closer to Him.
The altar is a place so sacred that a person can only enter there with a feeling of colossal trepidation, because this is the place where the Almighty is. I haven’t grown up to this yet - just being in the temple is enough for me. Both men and women in the temple are united, I don’t feel any division - we are all “One Body of Christ.” Just standing in the temple is already a lot for me. Of course, I would like to be on Mount Athos, because... there is a quiet and convenient place for prayer, but mother of God I decided that only men should be there, then I don’t strive there. The fact that women are not allowed to be on Mount Athos does not mean that men better than women. I think that Athonite monks need no women around, because... this is a place for intense prayer; there should be no temptations or temptations there. Athos is a holy place of prayer. The world needs these prayers. Therefore, there is no division - we are all one “Body of Christ”, this is God’s mercy for the whole world.
I think that the will and physical strength men are more developed than women. A woman is more attached to the earth. A man can purposefully walk towards his intended goal and not notice anything around him, but a woman sees the world more broadly. A man has fewer emotions and this helps him reach his goal. But a woman has a more developed heart and ability to love. It is more difficult for a man to open his heart.
I am not at all drawn to be a priest, because a priest is the image of Christ, who “laid down his life for his flock.” Christ Himself commanded this - this is how it was established. The priest must forget about himself, cut off his self for the sake of Christ - not everyone is ready for this.

Tutta Larsen, MTV presenter:
– I rather agree with the words of the apostle. If there is any source of vanity in the temple, it is most often due to the fault of women. The well-known “grandmothers” make comments to those who come to the temple. And often unchurched youth come in wearing pants and without headscarves. It is important at this moment not to scare them away - a person must grow up to everything himself. I believe that there should be no reproaches and condemnation in the church - this is unacceptable. But if the remark is made by the priest in a mild form, the parishioner will probably not be offended and will understand everything correctly. And, in general, the decision to come to the temple, i.e. taking the first step is a very difficult decision.
Once I came to the Danilovsky Monastery for Christmas, and they asked me to move away from the altar - this fact then greatly outraged and upset me. Now I'm okay with it.
A woman is more emotional, she can both create and destroy with her feminine energy and emotions, for example, harmonious relationships in family. A man must curb female energy and direct it in the right direction. And the strength of a woman, in my opinion, lies in the fact that she gives birth to children, keeps the hearth, that is, she is “living water”, which strengthens a man and makes him stronger.
I think that a woman cannot be a priest due to her weakness. She was probably created for someone else - for her husband and for her children.

Oksana Fedorova, host of the program “ Good night, kids":
– I come to the temple in order to be alone with myself, and men do not interfere with this at all. I think the apostle did not mean that a woman should remain silent in the church itself. He meant the family as a small Church. A wife should listen to her husband, that is, not take on a leadership role.
The Church has established that a woman should not enter the altar, and we should not argue with this. Although, I heard that nuns who have been in the monastery for a long time, that is, who have reached some spiritual heights, are allowed to enter the altar.
A woman is physically weaker than a man, but psychologically she is stronger. A lot rests on women’s shoulders: family, home, children and creating an atmosphere in the family. A woman does all the small work - she is more diligent. And when you need to make operational decisions and act quickly, here the palm is given to the man because he is more logical and sober. Women are dominated by emotions. This has its pros and cons. As they say, if a branch is tough, it breaks quickly, and if it is flexible, like a woman, then it is tenacious, capable of adapting to many things.
Eat nunneries, where the abbess of the monastery are women, but services are still conducted by men. When a priest serves, he becomes like Christ. Since Christ was a man, then, probably, the priest should be a man.

Elena Chudinova, writer, author of the book “Mosque Notre Dame of Paris»:
“I was simply shocked by the wave of attention and respect expressed to me by the clergy, which was caused by the appearance of my novel “Notre Dame Mosque.” I met so much approval, understanding, support and questions for me as a writer, as a thinker, from the clergy! Against the background of all this, it would be funny for me to say that there is discrimination against women in the church. But this is one side of the coin. On the other hand, I can consider myself as an ordinary, believing woman. And as such, I must - and this is completely natural and does not cause me any protest - remember that the wives are silent in the temple. We are Orthodox, we are not heretics who ordain women as bishops! And the woman in the temple does not preach. Apparently, this also implies some humility, that is, covering the head. After all, we still confess that we bear the sin of our ancestress Eve. Therefore, this is natural, and if this seems abnormal to someone, they need to choose another religion, a more “tolerant” and “politically correct” one.
But there are episodes that personally upset me. Recently, at a rally on Pushkin Square, out of respect for those who came to this rally, in accordance with my status as a married woman, I covered my head and put on a smart hat. And a very good priest asked me to take off my hat. Then I asked him, a little jokingly: “Father, why did you fool a married woman?” He answered me innocently: “If I had a handkerchief in my pocket, I would offer it myself.” Moreover, he was a worthy shepherd who commands every respect. Apparently, the implication was that the fashionable hat was somehow not good. You understand, I shouldn’t wear a headscarf, because I’m not a “woman”, my husband is not a “man”. By social status, I am a lady, and the appropriate headdress for a lady is a hat. A shawl, for example, but not a scarf. I think it’s a terrible relic when women with a diploma in art history or philology enter the temple, tying some ugly old woman’s white scarves!